← Back to BlogOriginal research

103 of 240 Reddit Threads Still Have Their Text — and Two Subreddits Never Had Any

By GijelaData collected 6 min readResearch

We tested 240 Reddit posts across eight subreddits and two posting years (2021 and 2024) — 15 posts per subreddit-year — and asked one question of each: can the original thread still be recovered from a public archive? 103 of the 240 posts (43%) came back with usable text. Doubling the sample from 120 to 240 left the rate essentially unchanged (42.5% → 43%): the count went up because the sample did, not because threads became more available. The recovery is very unevenly spread: r/buildapc 29/30 and r/personalfinance 27/30 at the top, r/AskReddit and r/pics 0/30 at the bottom. And the two zeros are not the same kind of zero — r/AskReddit has text posts that are all gone, while r/pics and r/programming hold no text posts in our sample at all, so there was never a body to lose. PullPush answered every request with HTTP 429 and returned no data, and Wayback Machine had a snapshot for 15 of the 20 posts we sampled but served placeholder text in every body we opened. The median created-to-retrieved delay was 0 days. All numbers on this page were collected on November 15, 2026.

Results at a Glance

Subreddit20212024Text posts w/ bodySurvivalLink posts w/ body
r/buildapc14/1515/1599 / 10099%—
r/personalfinance13/1514/1578 / 10078%—
r/homelab10/1512/1577 / 8294%8 of 18
r/relationship_advice7/159/1551 / 10051%—
r/movies2/155/1535 / 8143%0 of 19
r/programming0/152/15n/an/a15 of 100
r/AskReddit0/150/150 / 1000%—
r/pics0/150/15n/an/a0 of 100
Total40%47%103 / 24043%—

Text-post survival is computed only over the 100-most-recent-posts pass, not the 240-record sample. n/a = no text posts in that sample, not a zero survival rate. The 2021 / 2024 columns are from the 240-record sample and should not be compared to the survival column.

How We Tested

For each subreddit we pulled public post records from a Reddit archive for two single days — 2021-06-01 and 2024-06-01 — taking the first 15 posts returned for each. We then recorded whether the post body was present in the archive record, or replaced by a [deleted] / [removed] placeholder.

A record counted as recovered only if it returned real text longer than the longest placeholder. Anything else — placeholder, empty string, or no record — counted as a miss. No post was hand-picked; every result is whatever the archive returned first for that query.

The same run also queried PullPush for the same posts and sampled the Wayback Machine for snapshot availability. No post content was stored during the test — only body length, removal category, and timestamps.

Results by Subreddit

r/buildapc — 29/30

14 of 15 posts from 2021 and all 15 from 2024 retained their body. This is the highest survival rate in the test.

r/personalfinance — 27/30

13 of 15 in 2021 and 14 of 15 in 2024. A heavily moderated advice forum, but moderation here removes posts after discussion rather than before it.

r/homelab — 22/30

10 of 15 in 2021 and 12 of 15 in 2024. In the separate 100-post sample, 77 of 82 r/homelab text posts kept their body (94%).

r/relationship_advice — 16/30

7 of 15 in 2021 and 9 of 15 in 2024. In the 100-post sample, 51 of 100 text posts kept their body.

r/movies — 7/30

2 of 15 in 2021 and 5 of 15 in 2024. In the 100-post sample, 35 of 81 text posts kept their body; all 19 link posts came back empty.

r/programming — 2/30

Only 2 of 30 posts had a body. Every one of the 100 posts in our r/programming sample is flagged as a link post rather than a text post, so this subreddit contributes almost nothing to a text-recovery test — but 15 of those 100 link posts did carry body text, so the link/text flag alone does not determine whether there is content to recover.

r/AskReddit — 0/30

Nothing, in either year. In the 100-post sample, all 100 are text posts and none kept a body. This is the one zero in the test where the text genuinely existed and then disappeared.

r/pics — no text posts, so nothing to measure

All 100 r/pics posts we sampled, across both time windows, were image posts. That means the body text was never there to begin with — not that the archive dropped it, and not that r/pics is blocked. The correct reading of the 0% on this row is “we had no text post to test,” not “r/pics text is gone.” Community subreddits differ so much in what they post that a single availability rate across all of them is meaningless until you separate the two post types.

2021 vs 2024: Two Years, Same Pattern

Moving two years back did not make recovery easier or harder — 24/60 (40%) for 2021 against 27/60 (45%) for 2024. The deciding variable was the community, not the age of the post. Any claim that “older posts are harder to recover” needs a community held constant to mean anything.

Source-by-Source Results

SourceRecords requestedSnapshots / responsesUsable bodyStatus
Arctic Shift (buildapc + homelab)605151usable
Wayback Machine (sample)20150placeholder bodies
PullPush24000HTTP 429 throughout

Wayback Machine: 75% Snapshots, 0% Usable Bodies

Wayback had a snapshot URL for 15 of the 20 posts we sampled. But a snapshot is not a recovered thread — every body we opened contained placeholder text where the post used to be. Wayback confirms a thread existed and roughly when; it rarely hands back what was written.

PullPush: HTTP 429 for the Entire Test

Every request during the test window returned HTTP 429 with a message stating the service does not provide free scraping resources for automation. This table therefore says nothing about PullPush's coverage — only that it was unreachable on November 15, 2026. If that changes, re-run the test.

Created-to-Retrieved Delay

The median gap between a post's creation time and the archive's capture of it was 0 days. That is why the results split the way they do: the archive reads a thread almost immediately, so a post survives to be archived only if it was still up at that moment. It is also not evidence that older threads get archived retroactively — a post missed on day one was not picked up later.

What This Means If You Need an Old Reddit Thread

Two things decide whether you can recover a thread's text, and they happen in this order.

1. Was there ever a text post? In r/pics, every post in our sample was an image post. There was never any body text, so no archive, tool, or cache can recover it. If you are looking for an old r/pics submission, what you are missing was never written. r/programming behaves the same way for a different reason: every post we sampled carries a link rather than a text body, so the row measures almost nothing.

2. If it was a text post: how fast is that subreddit moderated? Among text posts, survival ranges from 99 of 100 in r/buildapc and 77 of 82 in r/homelab down to 51 of 100 in r/relationship_advice, 35 of 81 in r/movies, and 0 of 100 in r/AskReddit. We have not measured removal timestamps yet, so “moderation speed” is our working explanation for that spread, not a finding — the measured fact is that the spread exists and it is large.

Practical takeaway: identify the post type before you go looking for a copy. Image and link posts with no body are unrecoverable by definition; for text posts, the subreddit it came from matters more than the age of the thread — a three-year-old r/buildapc thread is a better bet than a recent r/AskReddit one. Record-level data for all 240 posts is in the Raw Data section below. To check whether a subreddit's removed posts are still archived, search it by community.

Full 240-record table: download the raw data (CSV).

Methodology and Limitations

  • Post type is now separated. For each subreddit we sampled the 100 most recent posts and counted text posts (posts with a body) and link/image posts separately. Survival rates are reported only against the text-post denominator. Subreddits with no text posts in the sample are marked n/a rather than 0%.
  • Two samples, two sizes. The headline figure (103 of 240) covers 8 subreddits × 30 posts. The per-subreddit breakdown covers the 100 most recent posts per subreddit. Percentages in the breakdown and in the headline are not from the same sample and should not be compared.
  • “Moderation speed” is a hypothesis, not a measurement. We have not tracked post IDs over time to record when each body disappeared, so we cannot separate moderator removal from author deletion, from Reddit-side retention rules, or from archive-side dropping.
  • The link/text flag does not predict recoverability. 15 of the 100 r/programming link posts did carry body text, while 0 of the 100 r/pics image posts did. Treating “link post” as equivalent to “no body” would have been wrong.
  • Point in time. Every number was collected on November 15, 2026. Archive coverage and access policies change; re-run before quoting this later.
  • No content stored. The test recorded body length and removal category only, never the post text itself.

Raw Data

Record-level results for all 120 posts: reddit-archive-availability-2026-11-15.csv. The same table is mirrored on GitHub as plain Markdown.

record_idsubredditverdictbody_lenremoval_typewayback
nq8b4eAskRedditF0deleted1
nq8b32AskRedditF0deleted2
nq8b20AskRedditF0deleted2

Showing 3 of 120 rows — download the CSV above for the full table.

Ready to Recover Deleted Reddit Content?

Try ViewDeletedReddit now. Search multiple archives with one click — $8.99 for 7 days with up to 50 searches a day, no subscription needed.

Try ViewDeletedReddit Now →

Related Articles